In the last few weeks, I had discussed about a simple yet intuitive way to pick equity mutual funds. In case you are new to this blog you can check the entire series here:
- Selecting an equity mutual fund is a pain in the neck. Find out why?
- What if Steve Jobs was an Indian Equity Investor
- How do we experience good performance?
- How to select equity mutual funds the eighty twenty investor way – Part 1
- How to select equity mutual funds the eighty twenty investor way – Part 2
- How to select equity mutual funds the eighty twenty investor way – Part 3
Now obviously all this is just theory if I don’t walk the talk.
So I have decided to invest my own money in two of the funds chosen, each and every month for the next 10 years.
Yes, you heard it right next 10 long years (Phew! It sounds equally intimidating and scary to me as well). Hopefully we can pull it off together 🙂
While all six fund managers are good, I wanted to keep my portfolio simple and so will stick to just two funds (good enough for providing adequate diversification).
I have chosen both the fund managers from the value basket (personal bias)
- Sankaren Naren – ICICI Prudential Large and Mid Cap Fund
- Rajeev Thakkar – Parag Parikh Long Term Equity Fund
You are free to pick any two and don’t bother too much on my choice.
The game plan is simple.
I will be investing Rs 30,000 every month in these two funds (15K each) for the next 10 years. Hopefully every year as my salary increases I will also be increasing my SIP amount by approximately 5-10%.
I will be reviewing my portfolio once every 6 months and the link to the review will be updated in this page.
Live Portfolio Updates
1.Discipline and Behavior check
I personally believe this will be the biggest determinant for the success of this plan.
Current Plan of action – 15,000 in ICICI Prudential Large & Mid Cap + 15,000 in Parag Parikh Long Term Equity Fund on the 5th of each and every month
- Aug-18 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Sep-18 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Oct-18 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Nov-18 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Dec-18 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Jan-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Feb-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Mar-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Apr-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- May-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- June-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
- Jul-19 Done – Rs 30K invested
1 year done! Increasing investment amount to Rs 40,000 every month 🙂
13. Aug-19 Done – Rs 40K invested
14. Sep-19 Done – Rs 40K invested
15. Oct-19 Done – Rs 40K invested
16. Nov-19 Done – Rs 40K invested
17. Dec-19 Done- Rs 40K invested
18. Jan-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
19. Feb-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
20. Mar-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
21. Apr-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
22. May-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
23. June-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
24. July-20 Done – Rs 40K invested
2 years done! Increasing investment amount to Rs 50,000 every month 🙂
25 Aug-20 Done – Rs 50K invested
26. Sep-20 Done – Rs 50K invested
27. Oct-20 Done – Rs 50K invested
28. Nov-20 Done – Rs 50K invested
29. Dec-20 Done – Rs 50K invested
30. Jan-21 Done – Rs 50K invested
31. Feb-21 Done – Rs 50K invested
32. Mar-21 Done – Rs 50K invested
All decisions will be documented here every 6 months (so that we can evolve our process based on feedback)
- Aug-18 – Rationale for picking the two funds – Link
- 6 month review: Link
- 1 year review: Link
- 1 Year 6 months: Link
- 2 Years: Link
3.Current Portfolio (started from 05-Aug-2018)
As on 08-Aug-2019
As on 11-Jul-2019
As on 14-Jun-2019
As on 10-May-2019
As on 15-Apr-2019
As on 15-Mar-2019
As on 13-Feb-19
As on 16-Jan-19
As on 06-Dec-18
As on 17-Nov-2018
As on 16-Oct-2018
As on 17-Sep-2018
1.What will determine the success of this whole plan?
Now while this question is better answered ten years down the line, this is what I believe will be the most important contributors to the success of my investment plan.
- Faith in Equities:
- Investing in Equities for the long run is basically a bet on human progress
- You are simply betting that entrepreneurs (who take higher risks) on an aggregate will get compensated with higher returns
- Discipline to invest regularly:
- Ability to save and invest regularly through good and bad times holds the key
- Patience to hang on through tough times:
- Market corrections are not a bug but a feature – and it is next to impossible to predict when the next one is coming, how steep the decline would be and how long it will last
- It is prudent to assume that our equity portfolios will go through a 30-50% decline at-least once in every decade
- 10-20% corrections should be expected to be a regular affair
- It is ok to realise that you wont be able to predict the fall and in fact you don’t need to predict the fall to create long term returns
- The way you behaviorally respond to a fall (which is completely under your control) is all that matters for your long term returns
- Choice of funds
- The idea is to pick funds managed by experienced fund managers with a
- Consistent and well communicated investment process/style
- Long term track record across market cycles (i.e periods covering up and down markets)
- Well diversified across large, mid and small companies
- The idea is to pick funds managed by experienced fund managers with a
The real deal breaker in this whole endeavor is not the choice of funds..
Instead its actually our ability to stay disciplined (invest every month) and stay patient through bad times (which is inevitable at some point in time).
And here is the best part..
Both these are completely in our control!
2.Is an SIP completely risk free?
How I wish!
Unfortunately SIP while it has a tremendous behavioral advantage, there are also certain risks that you must be aware of. You can read about it in detail here
3. Why do I not follow an asset allocation plan?
This is one of the common mistakes which most of us do. When you are in your 20s or 30s you forget the fact that you have a long investment time horizon & large human capital (i.e the amount of money you are yet to earn using skills, knowledge and experience, over the course of your career). This essentially means your current savings is a paltry amount compared to the expected corpus 15-20 years down the line.
I am in my early 30s and the amount that I am saving right now is a minuscule component if I take my entire future savings over the next 10-20 years in context. So to take advantage of this long investment time frame and human capital, I am going for a equity heavy portfolio as I have my short term requirements sorted through safer avenues such as fixed income funds etc
You can read more about this here
But if you have a large portfolio, then you will have to follow an asset allocation plan as wealth preservation takes a higher priority over wealth creation.
Just remember, if you are young – your ability to save is more important than picking the best fund!
3.Why do I do this?
Most of you must be going through the same problems as I am – difficulty to save, extremely complicated investment world and the problem of getting scared out of equities during a market fall.
The hope – is that you and me together will be able to solve this.
This journey which will be available in the public domain, will attempt to give you an idea of how living through an actual SIP portfolio looks like. Together, if we are able to stay invested without panicking through a bear market (which will inevitably happen sometime in the future) and invest regularly, then the long term results would be awesome and we could have our investment journey sorted!
I have always believed that investing needs to be simple and if we just got our behavior in place, all of us can have amazing results. This is my humble attempt to prove it.
Someday I hope of making you financially free and take pride in playing a small role in helping you live your dreams.
I know its a tall ask. But nevertheless..
Overall, if things work, then this page will be a inspiration for many people to start investing and appreciate the journey of what it really takes to be a long term investor.
If in case the whole concept is a failure, you can rip my case off via the comments explaining what a stupid jackass I was. For me while that would mean I would go down as a dumb guy, the best part is since every decision is documented you and I can always go back and analyze as to what actually went wrong. Then based on the actual evidence, you can avoid all my blunders.
Either way, its a win-win for you!
4.Any hidden agenda?
I am a nice guy and want to genuinely help you out. Err..Partly true.
But let me be brutally honest. I have a selfish motive as well.
Here goes my story..
Most of our parents were phenomenal savers (mine were for sure!). If you really look at why this happened, most of them took a huge loan and invested in a home early in their life. And this meant each and every month for the major part of their working years, they had to forcefully save and pay for the EMI. All their expenses were post their EMI.
Unfortunately I am not too keen on buying a home despite my mom trying day in and out to convince me.
The result – I am a terrible saver and a super spend thrift!
Since I have no loans, I end up spending a lot (especially impulse purchases). Adding to the pain, the Facebooks, Instagrams, Amazons, Flipkarts, Swiggys, Zomatos, Netflixes, Ubers etc of the world are making my savings habit almost next to impossible.
So unless and until I force myself to save I won’t be able to do it. The moment I have given a public commitment (to save 30k every month), then I suddenly become accountable to all of you and most importantly myself!
If I don’t save up every month, I will end up looking like a failure – the man who only preached.
So this is my selfish motive – to help myself get the discipline to save each and every month straight for 10 years – come what may!
5.Should you follow this portfolio?
The whole idea is to view this as a reference point and you can evolve your own plan based on this. Always focus on the thought process and my logic behind the plan and don’t blindly go by my choice.
Personally, I believe in this plan and hence I am investing my own money in it. So to trust me or not, I leave it to your own judgement.
6.Will there be tough times?
Obviously. There will be several periods where you will feel you would have been much better off investing in an FD instead. In a bear market, the portfolio returns will be extremely disappointing and I have no magic wand to save you from the pain of seeing temporary losses in your portfolio.
And again, at all points in time there will always be some other fund doing better than the ones I chose. I profess no special ability to spot future winners.
Simply put, this is a plain vanilla investment portfolio which will test our patience and discipline at several points of time. If you are not ready for it, then you need to evaluate safer options with lower return expectations.
7.Will I change the funds?
Yes, I will change the funds if
- The fund manager changes (because that is the basic premise of our investment)
- The performance over a cycle under performs the index
- The size of the fund becomes too big
- The fund manager does not stick to his communicated mandate and investment style
- Corporate governance issues
- Does not communicate in plain English during tough times
8. Should you pick the same funds?
Not at all. You can actually pick any fund based on your conviction. There are several good funds out there. The key is that we need to invest regularly and have the conviction to stay put through bear markets. The big idea is, if we can do it together, the journey of ups and downs become a lot more palatable.
9.Which platform do I use to invest?
As of now I use Kuvera. I find it simple and good enough. The newly launched Paytm Money might also be a decent option.
10.What about asset allocation?
Once my portfolio size grows to lets say 5 times my yearly spending, then I will start implementing an asset allocation strategy.
11.What is my risk profile?
I have my entire savings till date invested in equities (primarily via stocks). All my tax savings is in ELSS. I work for a wealth management firm and hence my career is also equity market dependent. My better half is an amazing entrepreneur and she runs a chain of dessert joints in Chennai called The Brownie Studio (if you drop in sometimes to this part of the country, try us out and do let me know). So in effect both of us are basic believers in the Indian entrepreneurship story and all our investments reflect this.
I am a very high risk taker and hence this SIP portfolio again falls into the pattern. My reason for choosing an SIP is because I am trying to automate my savings behavior.
If in case you have any other questions, do let me know. I shall try to answer this in the same post.
Until then, happy investing folks!
If you loved what you just read and think your friends might also find this us meful, share it with your friends and don’t forget to subscribe to the blog and join th 5000+ awesome people. Don’t miss out on the interesting investment insights delivered straight to your inbox every week. Cheers
Disclaimer: All blog posts are my personal views and do not reflect the views of my organization. I do not provide any investment advisory service via this blog. No content on this blog should be construed to be investment advice. You should consult a qualified financial advisor prior to making any actual investment or trading decisions. All information is a point of view, and is for educational and informational use only. The author accepts no liability for any interpretation of articles or comments on this blog being used for actual investments